Civic Seal Units · Unit 1
The Civics Capstone Through Youth and Government
Nine steps, nine pieces of evidence, one real issue
Civic Seal Units · Unit 1
The Civics Capstone Through Youth and Government
Nine steps, nine pieces of evidence, one real issue
Grades 11 to 12 (10 with advisor approval) · 10 to 14 weeks, one 45-minute class or delegation meeting per week plus independent work
Teacher note. Designed to run September through the state conference. Handouts: 1. Capstone Roadmap; 2. Issue Selection Form; 3. Evidence Log; 4. Stakeholder Map and Officials Contact Log; 5. Solutions Comparison Grid; 6. Reflection Prompts; 7. Capstone Rubric. You also need the bill and memorandum of support templates from Unit 2.
What this project may count toward
New York
- May count as the Civics Capstone Project (Civic Participation)
- The School Civic Readiness Committee decides
Connecticut
- May serve as the civic engagement project
- Can be documented as portfolio evidence where the district uses a portfolio
Rhode Island
- May count as the student-led civics project
- The district confirms
Teacher note. Nothing here is guaranteed. In NY the source lists the capstone as a possible 4 points if the Seal Committee accepts it; the committee decides. In CT the State Department of Education sets the criteria and districts decide whether to offer the seal. In RI the district confirms.
You will be able to
- Choose a real civic issue and gather evidence from three types of sources.
- Find the law that governs it, explain its history and name its gaps.
- Compare at least three solutions, including one that is not a new law.
- Write a Youth and Government bill and memorandum that amend the real law.
- Contact real officials, reflect on the four civic readiness domains, and present outside class.
Teacher note. Full objectives also include mapping stakeholders, communicating with at least two real officials or organizations and recording the responses.
Nine steps, nine pieces of evidence
Capstone Roadmap
1. Identify a civic issue. Issue Selection Form, signed.
2. Analyze with data and perspectives. Evidence Log, two sources of each type.
3. Identify root causes. Root Cause Memo and Original Law Worksheet.
4. Generate alternatives. Three solutions with precedents.
5. Evaluate solutions. Solutions Comparison Grid.
6. Develop strategies. Stakeholder Map and Action Plan.
7. Take informed action. Bill, memorandum, committee record, Contact Log, testimony, conference record.
8. Reflect. Reflection by the four domains.
9. Present. Presentation, audience and date, rubric.
Teacher note. These nine steps come from NYSED's sample capstone assignment (Handbook Appendix T). Each one maps to a Youth and Government task and a piece of evidence. This is Supporting Document 1.
The capstone issue test
Real people you can talk to. A law you can quote. Something you can act on this year.
"Climate change" fails. "No rule about idling buses outside the elementary school" passes.
Teacher note. Before Week 1, confirm with the school's seal coordinator that this unit will be accepted as the Civics Capstone and get the committee's rubric if it has one. Teams of two or three may share research and the bill, but every student keeps an individual Evidence Log, Contact Log and Reflection, and presents.
Phase One · 135 min
Identify and Analyze (Weeks 1 to 3)
- Week 1: Identify the issue45 min
- Week 2: Analyze with data and perspectives45 min
- Week 3: Identify root causes45 min
Teacher note. Calendar check: Steps 1 through 6 must finish before the delegation bill deadline. Steps 7 through 9 continue through and after the conference.
Apply the issue test
Does your issue affect people you can talk to, rest on a law you can quote, and allow action this year?
Listening session plan
List five people or groups affected by your issue. Draft three interview questions.
- Homework: hold at least three conversations before Week 2
- Record them on the Evidence Log
Issue Selection Form
- Your issue in one sentence
- The constituency you can talk to
- The law or policy involved
Teacher note. The advisor signs the form and forwards it to the Seal Committee for pre-approval. Signed form is the Step 1 evidence.
Three source types
You need at least two sources of each type.
- People affected: interviews, surveys
- Data: state or local statistics, school data, budgets
- Informed opinion: news, reports, officials, organizations on more than one side
Data hunt
Find at least one number that measures your issue. Log each source with one line on what it shows.
Teacher note. Model a state data portal search first.
Perspective check
Name one person or group who would oppose your likely solution. Commit to interviewing or reading them.
Five whys and the law
Ask "why" five times. At which "why" does the law or policy enter?
- Find the governing law
- Original Law Worksheet: citation, what it requires, when passed, what it does not cover
Teacher note. Use the Original Law Worksheet from Unit 2, Supporting Document 1.
Root cause memo
One page: the issue, the evidence, the root causes, the gap in the law.
- Peer review in pairs: flag any claim without a source
Teacher note. Close the week with a 5-minute advisor check of each Evidence Log.
Phase Two · 135 min
Solutions and Strategy (Weeks 4 to 6)
- Week 4: Generate alternative solutions45 min
- Week 5: Evaluate costs and benefits45 min
- Week 6: Plan for stakeholders45 min
At least three solutions
Write each solution in one sentence.
- A new or amended law
- A change in how a law is enforced or funded
- A non-legislative solution: a program, partnership or information campaign
Precedent search
For each solution, find one place that has tried it and what happened. Log it.
Teacher note. Another state, county, district or school counts. Then take 5 minutes to pick the solution to carry forward; keep the other two for the Comparison Grid.
Solutions Comparison Grid
Fill in the grid for all three solutions.
- Who benefits, who bears a cost
- Dollar cost, estimated with a source
- Feasible within a year?
- Unintended consequences
- Likely opponents and their best argument
Teacher note. The grid also asks for precedent and result, and the student's rating and reason. It becomes the Fiscal Implications and Justification sections of the bill.
Decision and defense
Write a paragraph defending your chosen solution against the strongest alternative.
Stakeholder Map
Supports
- Powerful
- Not yet powerful
Opposes
- Powerful
- Not yet powerful
Teacher note. Four boxes. For each party list names, titles and the reason each cares.
Map the stakeholders
Put every affected party in a box. Then name the officials with authority over your issue.
- A legislator
- A council member
- A school board member
- An agency office
Action plan
Choose your Phase Three actions. Give each a date and an owner.
- Write the bill; submit to delegation and conference
- Send the memorandum to the real sponsor or official
- Request a meeting or submit public comment
- Present to a community audience
Teacher note. End with a 5-minute advisor sign-off on each action plan.
Phase Three
Take Informed Action (Weeks 7 to 11)
- Week 7: Write the bill and memorandum
- Week 8: Delegation committee
- Week 9: Reach the real decision makers
- Week 10: The conference
- Week 11: Follow through
Teacher note. This phase runs through the conference. The source does not give minute-by-minute times for these weeks.
Write the bill and memo
Amend the actual law with underlines and strikeouts. Write the memorandum of support from your Comparison Grid.
- A peer does a format check with the Seal of State Approval checklist
- Submit to the delegation by its deadline
Teacher note. The checklist is in Storybook County Lesson 1, Writing a Bill.
Delegation committee
Record the strongest con argument and the committee's ranking. Then revise your bill.
Teacher note. Full Youth and Government committee format: author's opening, technical questions, con and pro debate, summation, ranking.
Reach the decision makers
Send your memorandum with a cover letter to at least two officials or organizations. Ask for a 15-minute meeting or a written response.
- Your state legislator
- The committee chair for your topic
- A local official or agency
- An organization on your Stakeholder Map
Teacher note. Where a public comment period or school board comment slot exists, students prepare and deliver two minutes of testimony.
Officials Contact Log
- Date
- Who
- How: letter, email, meeting, public comment
- What I sent or said
- Response received: quote or summary
- Follow-up owed
Teacher note. Minimum two contacts with responses. A non-response after two attempts counts if documented.
The conference
Present in committee and, if ranked, in chamber. Lobby other delegations.
- Collect: bill book page, committee ranking, chamber result
- Governor's action, if the bill reaches the Governor's Office
- Photographs and Press Corps coverage
Follow through
- Reply to any official who answered
- If your bill passed, send the result to the real sponsor
- If an official offered a meeting, take it
- Update your Contact Log
Phase Four
Reflect and Present (Weeks 12 to 13)
- Week 12: Reflect
- Week 13: Present
Write your reflection
750 to 1,000 words, organized by the four civic readiness domains.
- What I know now that I did not
- What skills I used
- How my view of participation changed
- What I would do next
Teacher note. Use Supporting Document 6. Peer and advisor review follow.
Reflection prompts
- Civic Knowledge: What do I know now about this law that I did not know in September? Which source changed my mind most?
- Civic Skills and Actions: Which skills did I actually use? Which was hardest, and what did I do?
- Civic Mindsets: Where did I meet someone who disagreed, and what happened?
- Civic Experiences: What did I do for the first time? What would I do next?
Teacher note. Shortened from Supporting Document 6; the handout has the full wording.
Present the capstone
Ten minutes plus questions: issue, evidence, alternatives, action taken, responses received, reflection.
Teacher note. NYSED requires a presentation to the school's Seal (Civic Readiness) Committee. Where possible add a second audience: a school board meeting, a YMCA board, a community organization or a family evening. The advisor completes the rubric and submits the portfolio to the Seal Committee.
Capstone rubric (100 rubric points)
- Issue and Evidence (Civic Knowledge): 20
- Root Causes and Alternatives: 15
- Evaluation and Strategy: 15
- The Bill and Memorandum: 15
- Informed Action (Civic Experiences): 20
- Reflection (Civic Mindsets): 10
- Presentation: 5
Teacher note. Each row is scored 4 to 1 and multiplied by its weight. The unit's standard is 70 or above with no row below 2, but the Seal Committee applies its own criteria. RI criteria are built in: student led (Issue Selection Form), reasons from evidence (Evidence Log, Root Cause Memo), connects federal, state and local policy (Original Law Worksheet, Stakeholder Map).
Before you go
- Which of the nine pieces of evidence do you already have?
- What is your next piece of evidence, and when is it due?
Teacher note. Support: offer pre-vetted issues with the law identified, let pairs split research and outreach, or allow a recorded interview in place of the written reflection. Challenge: a survey with at least 50 responses, a meeting (not just a letter) with an official, and a second presentation audience.
Your capstone is ready for the committee
Your school's committee or district decides how it counts
Eyes up here
Keyboard shortcuts and tips
- Right arrow or Page Down Next slide
- Left arrow or Page Up Previous slide
- Home or End First or last slide
- T Start or pause the timer
- R Reset the timer
- N Show or hide teacher notes
- B Blank the screen
- F Full screen
Project the slides from your laptop. Turn on Notes to see facilitation tips under the slide (keep them off while the screen is mirrored to students). Timed steps load their time into the timer automatically. Choose All slides to scroll or print every slide.